A RARE FIND! This is a hidden gem situated at the midpoint of Peninsula Lake, offering unparalleled panoramic lake views along with NW & SE exposure, allowing you to enjoy stunning sunrises and breathtaking mid-evening sunsets. The Circa 1920s cottage sits just steps from the waters edge. It feels alive with memories, each room a chapter in a rich history. Its a place where time seems to stand still, allowing you to step back and imagine the laughter, the conversations, and the quiet moments that have shaped its character over the decades. Nearly every room in the cottage boasts stunning lake vistas, framed by evergreens and ferns. At night, the sounds of the babbling creek that runs alongside is your natural sleep aide. The favorite room in the cottage must be the expansive 40-foot-wide screen in porch overlooking the waters edge where you can relax with a coffee or cold beverage or even dine Alfresco! The property features level land with 440 feet of sandy shoreline, making it easily accessible and perfect for all ages to play lawn games or water sports. Multiple lakeside guest cabins provide ample accommodation perfect for family gatherings or friends. Embrace the outdoors with activities such as boating, fishing, swimming, and kayaking right from your private dock with deep water. The cottage is part of a 4 Lake Chain offering over 40 miles of boating with direct access to Downtown Huntsville where you can experience the vibrant community, restaurants, shops, breweries and more! The surrounding area also offers amazing access to hiking trails in Algonquin and Arrowhead Provincial parks along with several golf courses and a local ski hill that ensures 4 season fun! The cottage, boathouse, guest cabins offer the rarity of grandfathered footprints, allowing for anyone looking to build their future dream cottage, endless possibilities. Don't miss the opportunity to make this a one-of-a-kind property of your own.
Single-familyProperty Type
6 garage spacesParking
Source:TREB #X12182887
Market trends in P1H, ON
Last updated October 2026
Sale-to-list price
--
Median sale price
--
Avg. days on market
--
Recently sold homes
--
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 1053 Put in Bay Lane Unit 2
Date
Event
Price
TREB #X12182887
Nov 1, 2025
Delisted
—
May 29, 2025
Listed
$2,595,000
+37
A RARE FIND! This is a hidden gem situated at the midpoint of Peninsula Lake, offering unparalleled panoramic lake views along with NW & SE exposure, allowing you to enjoy stunning sunrises and breathtaking mid-evening sunsets. The Circa 1920s cottage sits just steps from the waters edge. It feels alive with memories, each room a chapter in a rich history. Its a place where time seems to stand still, allowing you to step back and imagine the laughter, the conversations, and the quiet moments that have shaped its character over the decades. Nearly every room in the cottage boasts stunning lake vistas, framed by evergreens and ferns. At night, the sounds of the babbling creek that runs alongside is your natural sleep aide. The favorite room in the cottage must be the expansive 40-foot-wide screen in porch overlooking the waters edge where you can relax with a coffee or cold beverage or even dine Alfresco! The property features level land with 440 feet of sandy shoreline, making it easily accessible and perfect for all ages to play lawn games or water sports. Multiple lakeside guest cabins provide ample accommodation perfect for family gatherings or friends. Embrace the outdoors with activities such as boating, fishing, swimming, and kayaking right from your private dock with deep water. The cottage is part of a 4 Lake Chain offering over 40 miles of boating with direct access to Downtown Huntsville where you can experience the vibrant community, restaurants, shops, breweries and more! The surrounding area also offers amazing access to hiking trails in Algonquin and Arrowhead Provincial parks along with several golf courses and a local ski hill that ensures 4 season fun! The cottage, boathouse, guest cabins offer the rarity of grandfathered footprints, allowing for anyone looking to build their future dream cottage, endless possibilities. Don't miss the opportunity to make this a one-of-a-kind property of your own.
TREB #X10437991
Jan 6, 2025
Delisted
—
Aug 27, 2024
Listed
$2,795,000
+36
FIRST TIME OFFERED in over 100 years! This is a hidden gem situated at the midpoint of Peninsula Lake, offering unparalleled panoramic lake views along with NW & SE exposure, allowing you to enjoy stunning sunrises and breathtaking mid-evening sunsets. The Circa 1920s cottage sits just steps from the waters edge. It feels alive with memories, each room a chapter in a rich history. Its a place where time seems to stand still, allowing you to step back and imagine the laughter, the conversations, and the quiet moments that have shaped its character over the decades. Nearly every room in the cottage boasts stunning lake vistas, framed by evergreens and ferns. At night, the sounds of the babbling creek that runs alongside is your natural sleep aide. The favourite room in the cottage must be the expansive 40-foot-wide screen in porch overlooking the waters edge where you can relax with a coffee or cold beverage or even dine Alfresco! The property features level land with 440 feet of sandy shoreline, making it easily accessible and perfect for all ages to play lawn games or water sports. Multiple lakeside guest cabins provide ample accommodation perfect for family gatherings or friends. Embrace the outdoors with activities such as boating, fishing, swimming, and kayaking right from your private dock with deep water. The cottage is part of a 4 Lake Chain offering over 40 miles of boating with direct access to Downtown Huntsville where you can experience the vibrant community, restaurants, shops, breweries and more! The surrounding area also offers amazing access to hiking trails in Algonquin and Arrowhead Provincial parks along with several golf courses and a local ski hill that ensures 4 season fun! The cottage, boathouse, guest cabins offer the rarity of grandfathered footprints, allowing for anyone looking to build their future dream cottage endless possibilities. Don't miss the opportunity to make this a one-of-a-kind property your own.
As the MLS and public records start to fill up, we'll list the details here.
Property details
Public facts
Beds: —
Baths: —
Sq. Ft.: —
Stories: —
Lot Size: —
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: —
Year Renovated: —
Region: Muskoka District Municipality
Home facts updated by public records on Nov 21, 2024
Around this home
Schools
10.3km
Saint Mary's School
Public, JK-8 • Assigned
35.4km
St Dominic Catholic Secondary School
Public, 9-12 • Assigned
Provided by Local Logic
Lifestyle
Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic
Is this your home?
Track this home’s value and nearby sales activity
Nearby similar homes
Sorry, we don't have any nearby similar homes to display. See all homes for sale in P1H