Welcome to your turnkey waterfront retreat in the heart of Tobermory! Renovated, fully furnished, and move-in ready! This 4-season home/cottage offers the perfect opportunity for those seeking a family getaway, short-term rental / investment property or peaceful Bruce Peninsula escape. Set on a 66' x 165' waterfront lot in protected Hay Bay with easy access to Lake Huron, this property delivers the waterfront lifestyle buyers dream about! The shoreline is ideal for all ages, feat. a shallow swimming area perfect for children, and deeper water off the dock for kayaking, paddleboarding, or small boats. Spend your days exploring the bay, relaxing by the water, or enjoying spectacular sunsets and world-famous Dark Sky stargazing around the campfire. Offering 1,080sq. ft. of beautifully updated living space, the home was extensively renovated in 2021 with major upgrades incl. a new drilled well, septic system, plumbing, electrical, interior finishes, furnishings, and more. The bright and stylish interior features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms. A cozy fireplace that creates the perfect atmosphere, heat pump units provide efficient heating/cooling for year-round comfort, while the UV water treatment offers added peace of mind. The open-concept layout is designed for entertaining and relaxing, with stunning bay views from the main living space, dining area, and large deck. Whether preparing meals indoors or barbecuing outside, the waterfront backdrop makes every gathering memorable. Outside, the low-maintenance property allows more time for recreation and less time working. The detached garage provides excellent storage, workshop, or games room potential, while the greenhouse and elevated bunkie add extra charm and versatility. Located on a paved year-round road, you can bike into town for local amenities. Enjoy nearby access to the Bruce Trail, pickleball court, parks and all the outdoor recreation the Bruce Peninsula is known for. Start making unforgettable waterfront memories!
Single-familyProperty Type
9,583 sq ftLot Size
4 spacesParking
Listed by ASHLEY JACKSON• RE/MAX Grey Bruce Realty Inc.
Listed by AARON JACOBSON• ROYAL LEPAGE REAL ESTATE SERVICES LTD.
Basement is partial and unfinished with a sump pump
Wall cooling unit(s)
Heating & cooling
Propane heating
Heat pump
Wall cooling unit(s)
Exterior features
Private dock and lake access
Outdoor lighting
Deck and patio
Shed(s) and greenhouse
Partially cleared, terraced lot
Home design
Single family detached residential property
Faces south
Parking
4 parking spaces total with 1 covered space
Private detached garage
Security
Smoke and carbon monoxide detectors
Security system
Construction
Wood siding
Other construction materials
Asphalt roof
Utilities
Private well water
Septic tank
Sale and tax history for 59 Simpson Ave
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
TREB #X13105068
May 8, 2026
Listed
$799,000
TREB #X12448497
May 8, 2026
Delisted
—
Apr 14, 2026
Price Changed
$799,000
Oct 7, 2025
Listed
$850,000
+45
RENOVATED, TURN-KEY & WAITING FOR YOU! This renovated, turnkey, 4-season home or cottage getaway is located in the charming town of Tobermory and offers 1080sq. ft. of modern living. The home sits proudly on a 66' x 165' waterfront lot. The property's shoreline is highly desired with both a shallow swimming area (perfect for kids) along with access to deeper water off the dock for small boats or easy kayak launching. The shoreline is clean, rocky and protected in Hay Bay with easy access to Lake Huron. Get your canoe or kayak ready to enjoy life on the lake! The exterior of the property is low maintenance - why work, when you can relax. .. enjoy a campfire, watch the sunsets or take in the amazing stars at night. Inside you are greeted with a fully-furnished and turnkey 3 bedroom & 2 bathroom oasis. Fully renovated in 2021 - including a new drilled well, septic system, plumbing, electrical, interior finishes, furniture and more! Peace of mind and comfort afforded by the UV water treatment system and the two heat pump units providing both heat & cooling. Cozy up to the fireplace, enjoy family games at the table or entertain on the back deck overlooking the bay. Whether cooking inside or barbecuing outside, you have stunning views of the bay. The detached garage allows for storage, games room or a workshop. Plus, if you have a green thumb, the greenhouse structure waits for your personal touch to grow your own veggies or flowers. Kids will love the Bunkie structure on stilts! Bike into town, go out for dinner or grab an ice cream. Tobermory offers a dog park, Bruce Trail access and Pickleball court. Close to recreational activities and amenities Tobermory has to offer, yet tucked away on a paved year-round road. Move in and start making those family memories!
TREB #X12140653
Oct 1, 2025
Delisted
—
May 12, 2025
Listed
$875,000
+43
STUNNING TOBERMORY WATERFRONT PROPERTY! This is the one you have been waiting for. This renovated, turnkey, 4-season home is located in the charming town of Tobermory and offers 1080sq. ft. of modern living. The home sits proudly on a 66 x 165 waterfront lot. The property's shoreline is highly desired with both a shallow swimming area (perfect for kids) along with access to deeper water off the dock for small boats. The shoreline is clean, rocky and protected in Hay Bay with easy access to Lake Huron. Get your canoe or kayak ready to enjoy life on the lake! The property is low maintenance why work, when you can relax. .. enjoy a campfire, watch the sunsets or take in the amazing stars at night. Inside you are greeted with a fully-furnished and turnkey 3 bedroom & 2 bathroom oasis. Fully renovated in 2021 - including a new drilled well, septic system, plumbing, electrical, interior finishes, furniture and more! Peace of mind and comfort afforded by the UV water treatment system and the two heat pump units providing both heat & cooling. Cozy up to the fireplace, enjoy family games at the table or BBQ and entertain on the back deck overlooking the bay. The detached garage allows for storage, games room or a workshop. Close to all the recreation and amenities Tobermory has to offer, yet tucked away on a year-round road. A fantastic opportunity awaits to use the property both as personal use and investment with great rentability in a desired area. Move in and start making memories and income!
As the MLS and public records start to fill up, we'll list the details here.